As we move past the first quarter of the 2024-25 NHL season, the New York Islanders sit at an 8-9-5 record after 22 games. They are currently positioned mid-table in the Metropolitan Division and still in the playoff race, although they are not seen as true contenders. It’s clear that their roster requires enhancements, likely necessitating trades to bolster the team.
**Areas of Need for the Islanders**
The start of the season has featured both positives and negatives for the Islanders. With Mat Barzal and Anthony Duclair sidelined due to injuries, the forward lineup has developed two strong lines: Maxim Tsyplakov, Brock Nelson, and Kyle Palmieri constitute one line, while Anders Lee, Bo Horvat, and Jean-Gabriel Pageau form another. With Duclair back skating and Barzal expected to return soon, the Islanders might achieve a more balanced top-nine, yet they still require one additional forward to complete the group.
Historically, the team’s bottom six has struggled, but a new third line featuring Simon Holmstrom, Casey Cizikas, and Pierre Engvall has shown promise. This trio has contributed speed, scoring, and defensive skills, potentially positioning them as a solid fourth line once the roster is fully healthy.
Assessing the Islanders’ defense is complicated due to injuries to Alexander Romanov and Adam Pelech. Ryan Pulock has stepped up as the leading defender during their recent games, while Noah Dobson has experienced notable difficulties. Scott Mayfield has also quietly established himself as a dependable bottom-four defenseman. Isaiah George, just 20 years old, has performed admirably, recently recording his first NHL point, but overall, there are uncertainties surrounding the defense.
A heart issue was discovered in Mike Reilly after a concussion, leaving his recovery timeline uncertain. Dennis Cholowski has impressed in his brief time with the Islanders, though it remains to be seen if he can maintain his current level of play. Grant Hutton has been adequate but is expected to be demoted when Romanov or Pelech return.
Considering the Islanders’ potential once healthy and their limited cap space, significant roster additions may not be feasible, but smaller moves are still advisable. A priority should be adding a forward with speed and scoring ability to play with Duclair and Barzal. Additionally, bringing in a defensive specialist for the penalty kill and adding further depth would be beneficial.
**Strategic Trades**
Making trades merely for the sake of change is unwise; however, there are numerous affordable players the Islanders could target to enhance the roster. Ongoing discussions among fans about whether to buy or sell indicate that management remains committed to the current team.
The Pittsburgh Penguins are looking to trade from their surplus of forwards. Former Islander and 2015 first-round draft pick Anthony Beauvillier would be a logical choice due to his production, team chemistry, manageable contract, and positional fit. Depth additions like Blake Lizotte and Noel Acciari, known for their two-way play, may also be a good direction. Moreover, players like Drew O’Connor and Michael Bunting would complement Barzal and Duclair well, given their scoring potential and previous success with Sidney Crosby.
The Islanders could potentially make their first trade with the Utah Hockey Club by acquiring Michael Carcone, a 28-year-old who scored 21 goals last season but has struggled to secure a roster spot this year. Earning the league minimum salary of $775,000, he could likely be obtained for a sixth or seventh-round pick.
